Stay up-to-date on the companies, people and issues that impact businesses in Syracuse, Central New York and beyond.
Pizza Hut property near Auburn sold for $235,000
SENNETT — The 386 Grant Avenue (Route 5) property in the town of Sennett, on which a Pizza Hut restaurant sits, was recently sold. GC Pizza Hut REO Holdings, LLC, a Delaware-based limited liability company, purchased the 1.2-acre property and 2,800-square-foot building, according to John Bouck, owner/broker of Bouck Real Estate in Auburn, which arranged […]
Become a Central New York Business Journal subscriber and get immediate access to all of our subscriber-only content and much more.
Click here to purchase a paywall bypass link for this article.
SENNETT — The 386 Grant Avenue (Route 5) property in the town of Sennett, on which a Pizza Hut restaurant sits, was recently sold.
GC Pizza Hut REO Holdings, LLC, a Delaware-based limited liability company, purchased the 1.2-acre property and 2,800-square-foot building, according to John Bouck, owner/broker of Bouck Real Estate in Auburn, which arranged the sale.
According to Bouck, the previous owners of the property, R.S. Vescio Revocable Family Trust, had owned the real estate only for many years, with a long-term lease to Pizza Hut. The family trust sought to divest itself of some of its property, including the Grant Avenue parcel. Subsequently, the Bouck Real Estate firm sold the property, to a national franchisee.
The purchasers of the property, GC Pizza Hut REO Holdings had recently acquired the local Pizza Hut franchise, but were interested in owning the real estate, instead of leasing, as they have been doing. Bouck said that when the real estate became available, he contacted them to determine if they would like to acquire it.
GC (Golden Child) Pizza Hut REO Holdings is one of the largest Pizza Hut franchisees in the U.S., operating more than 97 restaurants in 7 states, according to Bouck. While a number of the Pizza Hut properties, in which GC has a franchise interest, have been closed over the past year, including two eateries in the Syracuse area, the company showed its continuing interest in keeping the Auburn–area Pizza Hut open. According to Bouck, the lease was set to expire in about one year, and the company wanted to ensure that it would be able to retain the real estate and the location, and not just the franchise.
The sale included the land and the building and did not include the Pizza Hut business, which GC Pizza Hut REO Holdings already owned as a franchisee, per Bouck.
“The GC franchise company is a very aggressive, and growing group, and I would anticipate there would be further upgrades and changes in this local operation, which will also show their commitment to the area and the people. We are certainly looking forward to a continuing relationship with the company,” Bouck said in a release.
State Needs to Take Over Cost of Medicaid to Reduce Property Taxes
Everyone knows that New York’s property taxes are among the highest in the nation. According to the Tax Foundation, New York’s state and local property taxes on a per-capita basis were $2,789 making them the 4th highest in the nation. The main reason is unfunded mandates. In Oswego County, 80 percent of the county’s budget
Become a Central New York Business Journal subscriber and get immediate access to all of our subscriber-only content and much more.
Click here to purchase a paywall bypass link for this article.
Everyone knows that New York’s property taxes are among the highest in the nation. According to the Tax Foundation, New York’s state and local property taxes on a per-capita basis were $2,789 making them the 4th highest in the nation. The main reason is unfunded mandates.
In Oswego County, 80 percent of the county’s budget goes toward paying for state and federal mandates. The largest unfunded mandate is Medicaid- which accounts for 55 percent of the county’s entire property tax levy. This is similar for counties throughout the state.
Medicaid is a joint federal and state program largely administered by states and is paid for with federal, state, and local funds. It provides health insurance for low-income families and individuals. Currently, about one-third of New York residents receive Medicaid assistance.
States have the flexibility to design their Medicaid programs and therefore, eligibility and benefits under Medicaid vary widely from state to state. For example, after the federal government enacted Obamacare (the Affordable Care Act), New York chose to expand the program to allow more low-income, non-elderly people to qualify for Medicaid. States also have the authority to pass some of the cost of the program to the counties which, in turn, raise revenue through property and sales tax. New York is one of 18 states that requires counties to cover some of the non-federal costs associated with Medicaid.
Recognizing the tremendous burden the local share of Medicaid was placing on property owners, in the 2012-13 budget, the state capped the counties’ Medicaid costs. This was a good start. However, more needs to be done. Oswego County is still sending close to $24 million each year to Albany for Medicaid. In order to provide full relief from this mandate, I sponsor legislation that provides for the full takeover of Medicaid over a 10-year phase-in period.
In tandem with the Medicaid takeover, the bill would freeze property taxes at the 2018 level then assume the property tax growth of local governments or school districts that stay within the 2 percent tax cap. In addition, the legislation requires the state create a Real Property Tax Redesign Team. The team would be tasked with reducing mandates and to find at least $500 million in annual recurring savings. A similar team called the Medicaid Redesign Team — comprised of representatives of health-care workers, Medicaid recipients, and hospitals — was created in 2011 that recommended more than 70 solutions the state used to help Medicaid costs from spiraling further out of control. The first year alone it saved taxpayers an estimated $2.3 billion.
Certainly, at any level of government efficiencies can be found. However, New Yorkers should be skeptical of any politician who says property taxes are high because of mismanagement by county officials. State mandates are causing your taxes to be high.
William A. (Will) Barclay is a Republican member of the New York State Assembly representing the 120th Assembly District, which includes Oswego, New York, and portions of Onondaga, Jefferson, and Oswego counties. Contact him at barclaw@assembly.state.ny.us; (315) 598-5185; or friend him on Facebook.
Debate in Congress has always been contentious. The levels of vitriol may seem especially acute these days, but confrontation is not new. I can remember times on Capitol Hill when “debate” was actually more of a screaming match than a civil discussion. Back then, we had a colleague who invariably stepped forward at these times
Become a Central New York Business Journal subscriber and get immediate access to all of our subscriber-only content and much more.
Click here to purchase a paywall bypass link for this article.
Debate in Congress has always been contentious. The levels of vitriol may seem especially acute these days, but confrontation is not new. I can remember times on Capitol Hill when “debate” was actually more of a screaming match than a civil discussion.
Back then, we had a colleague who invariably stepped forward at these times to remind each side that if we wanted to get anything done — rather than just shout at each other for the cameras — we had to have a measure of trust in one another. We used to call this his “Trust is the coin of the realm speech.” And though we joked about it, we appreciated it. Because he was right.
Representative government depends on trust. It depends on trust among policymakers in Congress, even when they don’t agree with one another. It depends on popular trust in the people who make decisions on Capitol Hill and in the White House. It depends on trust in those who are charged with implementing those laws. And it requires trust in the institutions in which those decisions are produced and implemented.
We might have joked about my long-ago colleague’s speech, but trust really is the coin of the realm. It is a bedrock requirement of democratic governance. If there’s nothing but cynicism, deep suspicion, and lack of confidence in the system, it cannot work.
To understand how interwoven trust must be within the system, think about it from the point of view of ordinary citizens. We have to believe that our voices will be heard, listened to, and taken into consideration in the halls of power.
This means that those in power must be accountable, and that the institutions they serve in will function in predictable, rule-based ways. Which is why it is so damaging when government acts in ways that diminish trust.
If you feel that government is just helping corporations and rich people, you lose confidence in the system. If people see a government that tolerates a high degree of economic inequality in the country, and great disparities in opportunities between rich people and middle-class people, they no longer trust that system.
Yet for representative democracy to work, public officials, politicians, and policymakers have to have a sufficient level of support from ordinary people. You and I have to believe that our representatives will in fact level with us rather than present half-truths and distortions, and will act in our interests. Similarly, for government to have any standing in our lives, we have to have confidence in the experts, technocrats, and frontline staff who make the system work.
This means, in turn, that government has to be able to deliver the goods, the services, the protections that people expect. So the performance of the government — its efficiency and effectiveness — is fundamental to the success of representative democracy.
The same with our elected representatives. If they can’t show they’re able to function according to the rules, traditions, and norms that we expect, if they are unable to demonstrate durability in the face of adversity, if they are unable to acknowledge the facts, if they cannot rise above division and gridlock to negotiate to get things done, then we lose faith. Which may explain why so many have become suspicious not only of our government, but also of one another.
Ironically, one cure for this lack of trust is more exposure to the system, through engagement and participation in politics or in civic life. If people are regular participants in political parties, clubs, organizations, or associations of all kinds in their communities, they are much more likely to carry some level of trust in government. And to the extent they don’t do these things, public life seems more distant and less trustworthy.
There is no doubt that my colleague was right. If the various levels of government don’t enjoy the trust of the people, if within each level the participants don’t trust one another, then representative democracy doesn’t work.
Which is why the low levels of trust we see in the United States today are so worrisome. How far down this road can we go before we lose the ability to function effectively as a democracy?
Lee Hamilton is a senior advisor for the Indiana University (IU) Center on Representative Government, distinguished scholar at the IU School of Global and International Studies, and professor of practice at the IU School of Public and Environmental Affairs. Hamilton, a Democrat, was a member of the U.S. House of Representatives for 34 years, representing a district in south central Indiana.

The Village Basement formally opens under new ownership
NEW HARTFORD — The Village Basement Consignment Shop in New Hartford has formally opened under its new owners. The New Hartford Chamber of Commerce welcomed the new owners — Amanda Hanna of Barneveld and Kate Hoover of Newport — on Nov. 10 with a ribbon cutting and grand reopening celebration at the store at 70
Become a Central New York Business Journal subscriber and get immediate access to all of our subscriber-only content and much more.
Click here to purchase a paywall bypass link for this article.
NEW HARTFORD — The Village Basement Consignment Shop in New Hartford has formally opened under its new owners.
The New Hartford Chamber of Commerce welcomed the new owners — Amanda Hanna of Barneveld and Kate Hoover of Newport — on Nov. 10 with a ribbon cutting and grand reopening celebration at the store at 70 Genesee St. The event commemorated the Village Basement changing hands after 19 years under former owner, Diane Evans, according to a chamber news release.

Hanna and Hoover are two childhood friends who discovered the shop while in college, and have been regular customers ever since, according to the New Hartford Chamber.
The pair formed a business partnership and took over the Village Basement on Oct. 1. “Their family members helped with some updated aesthetics, but otherwise, the shop is still very much like it’s been for years,” the release stated.
The Village Basement manages a consignment inventory of women’s clothing, accessories, and home décor.
The shop is situated in the basement of the 70 Genesee St. building, which contains six other businesses. The shop is located in the back and offers “plenty of parking,” the chamber said.
The Village Basement is open Tuesday through Saturday; its hours are 9:30 a.m. to 5:30 p.m., except for Thursday, when the shop is open until 7 p.m. It accepts consignments each day.
St. John Fisher, SU College of Law agree to 3+3 program for Fisher students
“A select group” of students at St. John Fisher College will have the chance to pursue both an undergraduate and law degree in six years under an agreement between Fisher and the Syracuse University College of Law. St. John Fisher is located in the Rochester suburb of Pittsford. It’s called a 3+3 legal education accelerated
Become a Central New York Business Journal subscriber and get immediate access to all of our subscriber-only content and much more.
Click here to purchase a paywall bypass link for this article.
“A select group” of students at St. John Fisher College will have the chance to pursue both an undergraduate and law degree in six years under an agreement between Fisher and the Syracuse University College of Law.
St. John Fisher is located in the Rochester suburb of Pittsford.
It’s called a 3+3 legal education accelerated program (LEAP), which is aimed at “minimizing the cost of their education,” St. John Fisher said in a Nov. 7 news release.
To be considered for the program, students must meet a set of requirements for both institutions.
At Fisher, they must enroll as first-year students, complete the school’s first-year program, core curriculum, major, and minor requirements, per the release.
They also need to consult with a LEAP advisor to discuss educational and career goals and earn a cumulative undergraduate grade-point average of 3.5 or higher. Students also must complete the Law School Admission Test (LSAT) with a score at or above the median LSAT score for the College of Law’s previous year’s enrolled class.
Students also have to submit an application to the College of Law through the Law School Admission Council during their third and final year at Fisher.
“The partnership with St. John Fisher College provides its students with an accelerated path to the College of Law and its unique offerings, including our top-rated Advocacy Honor Society program, innovative research centers focused on national security, technology commercialization and disability law, and our expansive externship opportunities offered around the country, among others,” Denee Page, assistant dean of enrollment management at the Syracuse University College of Law, said in the Fisher news release.
This agreement is the fourth 3+3 LEAP program at Fisher. The school also holds agreements with Michigan State University College of Law, University at Buffalo Law School, and Ohio Northern University.
SCORE Syracuse guided 65 business ventures in FY18
SYRACUSE — The Syracuse chapter of SCORE provided guidance to about 65 business ventures in its territory during federal fiscal year 2018 that ended Sept. 30. The nonprofit SCORE is an organization of business entrepreneurs working to help small-business owners, entrepreneurs, and those who are “kind of dreaming” about opening a small business or having
Become a Central New York Business Journal subscriber and get immediate access to all of our subscriber-only content and much more.
Click here to purchase a paywall bypass link for this article.
SYRACUSE — The Syracuse chapter of SCORE provided guidance to about 65 business ventures in its territory during federal fiscal year 2018 that ended Sept. 30.
The nonprofit SCORE is an organization of business entrepreneurs working to help small-business owners, entrepreneurs, and those who are “kind of dreaming” about opening a small business or having their own business, says Marty Doto, a mentor with the SCORE Syracuse chapter. He calls it “trying to pay it forward.”
“We’re trying to take our expertise and our knowledge and share it with those folks to help them succeed as we did in our careers,” he says.
Doto, who has been a mentor for a “little over two years,” also handles marketing and communications for the organization. Doto, who is now retired, says he worked in the insurance industry both in upstate New York and elsewhere
SCORE Syracuse’s territory is a five-county area around Syracuse, including Onondaga, Oswego, Cortland, Madison, and Oneida counties. The SCORE Syracuse office is affiliated with the office in Utica.
“It’s a pretty broad reach and the clients can come from anywhere, and we can also do video conferencing,” Doto notes.
He describes SCORE as a “resource partner” with the Syracuse district office of the U.S. Small Business Administration (SBA), which provides “a lot of our referrals.”
Client meetings are by appointment. SCORE will meet with a client at the Syracuse SBA office or wherever it’s most convenient because the goal is to have recurring visits and mentoring sessions.
SCORE provides guidance for a lot of startups. About two-thirds of its clients are seeking help because they want to start a new business. The other one-third are people who are already in business, so SCORE works to be available to them as they continue to face different challenges.
“The goal is that we’re working with each other over years, not just over weeks or months,” Doto says.
About SCORE
SCORE has operated since the 1960s and “just about as long here in Central New York,” Doto says. SCORE started as an organization of retired executives “but that’s certainly not our make up now,” he adds.
The organization has members and mentors who are retired and semi-retired, along with small-business owners and entrepreneurs who are still working.
The name SCORE, for a time, was short for senior corps of retired executives, but that’s no longer the case. “We don’t consider it an acronym for anything. It’s just the name of the organization,” Doto says.
When asked how business owners become mentors with SCORE, he says “a lot of times, it’s word of mouth” and a recommendation from someone with whom the mentor is acquainted. Former SCORE clients sometimes decide to join the organization because they appreciate the help that the organization provided, he notes.
“When it was their time, they decided to join the organization so that they could give back,” says Doto.
The Syracuse chapter of SCORE has about 35 mentors as of now, but it also has subject-matter experts based on a client’s needs. It also has members and volunteers who conduct workshops.
“Because we’re part of a national organization, we can tap resources on the national basis as well … so the client gets a broad base of expertise to pull from,” says Doto.
Walters to become first woman to chair the Syracuse University board of trustees
SYRACUSE — The woman who has been serving as a vice chair on the Syracuse University board of trustees will become the first female to lead the board. It unanimously elected Kathleen Walters as its next chairperson, the university said in a Nov. 12 news release. Walters, who graduated from Syracuse University in 1973, will
Become a Central New York Business Journal subscriber and get immediate access to all of our subscriber-only content and much more.
Click here to purchase a paywall bypass link for this article.
SYRACUSE — The woman who has been serving as a vice chair on the Syracuse University board of trustees will become the first female to lead the board.
It unanimously elected Kathleen Walters as its next chairperson, the university said in a Nov. 12 news release.
Walters, who graduated from Syracuse University in 1973, will succeed current board chair Steve Barnes, whose term ends in May 2019.
“I am deeply honored to have been selected by my peers to serve as the chair of my alma mater’s board of trustees,” Walters said. “Syracuse University played a significant role in my life’s trajectory, both professionally and personally, and I am thankful to have the opportunity to work on behalf of the institution that provided me such a strong education. I am humbled by the support I have received from my fellow trustees, Chancellor Kent Syverud and other members of the Syracuse University community, and look forward to taking on this critically important role.”
About Walters
Walters currently serves as executive VP of Atlanta, Georgia–based Georgia-Pacific LLC (GP) and group president of its consumer-products group. Georgia-Pacific is one of the largest retail and commercial tissue and tabletop businesses in North America, spanning more than 40 operating facilities and employing 15,000 people.
She has held her roles with Georgia-Pacific since 2007, and previously served in other executive positions at the company. Prior to joining GP in 2004, Walters held a number of key leadership positions in Europe and the U.S. for Scott Paper Co. and its parent company, Irving, Texas–based Kimberly-Clark Corp. (NYSE: KMB). She also served as CEO of SAPPI Fine Paper North America.
“Kathy brings a unique perspective, as well as a wealth of knowledge and experience to the role of board chair,” Chancellor Syverud said in the release. “She is a strong leader and a tireless advocate for Syracuse University. Kathy will make an excellent chair. I am confident great things will happen under her leadership.”
“Syracuse University is incredibly fortunate to have someone of Kathy’s caliber taking over the leadership of the board of trustees,” Barnes said. “The combination of her strategic and governance experience makes her well positioned to be our next chair.”
Walters has been “very active” in supporting the university along with her husband, Stanley Walters, who graduated in 1972, per the release. He was a two-year letterman in football at Syracuse University and went on to play in the National Football League with the Philadelphia Eagles, and after retiring was a radio color commentator.
Kathleen Walters regularly speaks with Syracuse University students, participating in the Syracuse Immersion Program in Atlanta, and she hosted a regional Syracuse-sponsored event in 2014, called “Power Up Atlanta.” It was a women’s networking symposium featuring Kristi Andersen, professor of political science in Syracuse’s Maxwell School of Citizenship and Public Affairs, and prominent Syracuse alumni, the university said.
The Walters reside in Atlanta. They are the parents of two grown children, Stanley and Elizabeth, who also live in Atlanta, per the release.

State agriculture commissioner unveils nearly $1.4M to support New York’s specialty crop industry
New York State Agriculture Commissioner Richard A. Ball last month announced that more than $1.36 million in government funding will support 12 advanced research, education, and marketing projects to help specialty crop farms across New York State “grow and remain competitive.” The New York State Department of Agriculture and Markets secured the grant through the
Become a Central New York Business Journal subscriber and get immediate access to all of our subscriber-only content and much more.
Click here to purchase a paywall bypass link for this article.
New York State Agriculture Commissioner Richard A. Ball last month announced that more than $1.36 million in government funding will support 12 advanced research, education, and marketing projects to help specialty crop farms across New York State “grow and remain competitive.”
The New York State Department of Agriculture and Markets secured the grant through the U.S. Department of Agriculture’s (USDA) Specialty Crop Block Grant program.
New York’s specialty crops include fruits, vegetables, tree nuts, maple syrup, and honey, and are among the state’s most valuable agricultural products. Since the USDA began the program in 2006, New York State has been awarded $12.5 million for 129 specialty crop projects across the state.
“This grant will help our growers ensure that some of our most valuable agricultural crops are more resilient, and that our farmers can remain competitive in today’s marketplace,” Ball said in a news release.
The research grants will be used to find ways to improve soil health and pest management in beets, onions, corn, and cider apples. Research supported by the grants will also help improve apple-storage practices and investigate kelp aquaculture techniques, Ball’s office said. The remaining funds will go to five projects led by the New York State Department of Agriculture and Markets to help growers with Good Agricultural Practices (GAP) certification and to market and promote specialty crops, including New York’s Concord grape industry.
The funding provides $600,000 for seven grower research/education projects. These projects were identified through a competitive program supported by the New York Farm Viability Institute.
Research projects were awarded in several areas, including production, disease resistance, and harvesting. They include:
• Monitoring pathogenicity of fire blight strains
• Management of wireworms in organic and conventional production systems
• Sustainable foliar disease control within the New York table beet industry
• Management of disease and fungicide resistance in New York–grown onions
• Defining tillage systems for vine crops and sweet corn on muck soils
• Proper harvesting and storage techniques for New York apples
• Aquaculture production of kelp
Cornell University will lead six of the seven research projects, with the SUNY Research Foundation leading kelp research, the release stated.
An additional $761,000 will fund five Department of Agriculture and Markets-led marketing projects to further promote the Empire State’s specialty crops, including:
• Promotion of the Concord grape industry
• Support for the state’s specialty crops at trade shows
• Advertising and promotion of New York’s specialty crop producers
• Expansion of Good Agricultural Practices (GAP) reimbursements to specialty crop growers
• Improving marketing services, such as business-to-business websites, for specialty crop producers
Grant funds are awarded to applicants whose projects have statewide significance to the specialty crop industry and build knowledge to help all growers.
Several leaders of associations of specialty crop producers in New York were quoted in the news release applauding the funding. Among them, Helen Thomas, executive director of the New York State Maple Producers’ Association, said, “The specialty crop funding has been important to New York Maple for several years. The maple crop production in New York State has nearly tripled in the last 15 years due in part to projects funded by this program. Going forward, the funds will be used for marketing the crop so that New York State becomes known as a maple-producing state.”
The specialty crop block grant program is administered through the New York State Department of Agriculture and Markets and its Specialty Crop Advisory Committee. The New York Farm Viability Institute evaluates the research proposals, reviews applications, submits recommendations to the department, and then tracks the progress of the projects, the release explained.
Report: Veteran entrepreneurs face more acute financing shortfalls
It cites smaller loan requests, higher credit risk, and lack of information as possible causes The Federal Reserve Bank of New York and the U.S. Small Business Administration (SBA) on Nov. 8 issued a report, called “Financing their Future: Veteran Entrepreneurs and Capital Access.” The report evaluates the state of entrepreneurship for military veterans by
Become a Central New York Business Journal subscriber and get immediate access to all of our subscriber-only content and much more.
Click here to purchase a paywall bypass link for this article.
It cites smaller loan requests, higher credit risk, and lack of information as possible causes
The Federal Reserve Bank of New York and the U.S. Small Business Administration (SBA) on Nov. 8 issued a report, called “Financing their Future: Veteran Entrepreneurs and Capital Access.” The report evaluates the state of entrepreneurship for military veterans by outlining current literature on veteran entrepreneurship, and presenting new small-business credit data from the Federal Reserve Banks’ 2017 Small Business Credit Survey (SBCS).
The report found that, despite similar demand for financing, veteran-owned business applicants were more likely than nonveteran-owned business applicants to face “financing shortfalls,” where they received less than the amount of credit they sought, according to a New York Fed news release. They also had lower approval rates at the most popular lenders, and the amount of SBA-guaranteed loans that they have received has increased more slowly over time than for non-veterans. The report explains that this discrepancy in financing experiences could be attributable to the smaller loan amounts that veteran-owned businesses seek, higher credit risk, and lack of information. Find the report at: (https://www.newyorkfed.org/medialibrary/media/smallbusiness/2017/Report-on-Veteran-Entrepreneurs-and-Capital-Access.pdf).
The 2018 SBCS is currently being fielded, and small-business owners can help further address information gaps on small business financing by taking this survey, per the release.
“To solve a problem, it’s critical first to understand its scope. This report presents the most substantial evidence to date of the challenges veteran-owned businesses face in accessing capital,” Claire Kramer Mills, New York Fed assistant VP, said in the release. “By understanding how much credit veteran-owned businesses are seeking, where they’re applying, and the nature of their financing challenges, policy makers and service providers can better help veterans overcome financing shortfalls.”
Larry Stubblefield, associate administrator of SBA’s Office of Veterans Business Development, added, “Clearly, aspiring veteran entrepreneurs can benefit from preparation and training to start their businesses and succeed in the marketplace. This report highlights the value of SBA-partnered resources like the Boots to Business entrepreneurship training program, which helps veterans as they navigate the challenges in financing, starting and growing their companies.”
Key findings from the report
Veterans are less likely to be self-employed today than in the past, according to U.S. Census Bureau data. When they do start businesses, most are small and often report lower sales. The labor force self-employment rate for veterans has declined 33 percent over the past 20 years, as compared to a 9 percent drop for nonveterans.
A majority (60 percent) of veteran-owned businesses have 1 to 4 employees. These businesses tend to have lower sales than nonveteran-owned businesses of the same size, and this difference holds across industries, the news release stated.
Demand for financing was similar for veteran- and nonveteran-owned businesses (42 percent and 40 percent applied for financing, respectively).
Despite similar demand for financing, veteran-owned business applicants were more likely to experience a financing shortfall (60 percent) than nonveteran-owned business applicants (52 percent).
The approval rates for veteran-owned business applicants for loans, lines of credit, and cash advances were about 10 percent lower than for nonveteran-owned business applicants, irrespective of the lending source.
Since 2010, SBA-guaranteed loans have increased by 48 percent for veteran borrowers compared to an 82 percent increase for nonveteran borrowers, per the release.
Reasons for financing shortfalls
The report, with conclusions based on new SBCS and SBA data, presents three possible explanations for the discrepancy in funding outcomes for veterans and nonveterans: smaller loan amounts sought, credit-report concerns, and a need to seek advice when completing loan applications. The findings include:
• 60 percent of veteran-owned business applicants sought $100,000 or less in financing. Processing smaller loans can be costly for larger lending sources due to fixed transaction costs, so they may be less likely to approve these loans.
• 61 percent of veteran-owned businesses had high credit scores, compared to 69 percent of nonveteran-owned businesses. Also when firms were denied credit, veteran-owned businesses cited insufficient credit history or collateral as reasons more often (47 percent and 42 percent respectively) than nonveteran-owned businesses (36 percent and 35 percent respectively).
• Veteran business owners were more likely to submit multiple loan applications, and yet had lower approval rates. Observations by SBA officials indicate that business owners may lack understanding of, or lack preparation for the loan-application process.
Research conclusions and forward thoughts
Based on these conclusions, the report cites three ways policymakers and service providers could potentially help veterans overcome financing shortfalls.
• Encouraging an expanded focus on service to veteran-owned businesses through the Treasury Department’s Community Development Financial Institutions Fund, which supports lending to underserved segments;
• Providing mentorship opportunities to assist veteran entrepreneurs in putting together business and financing strategies before meeting with a lender; and,
• Raising awareness about the organizations that are currently working to address
The Federal Reserve Banks’ Small Business Credit Survey collects information about business performance, financing needs, and choices and borrowing experiences of firms with fewer than 500 employees. Responses to the SBCS provide insight into the dynamics behind aggregate lending trends and about noteworthy segments of small businesses, according to the release. The results are weighted to reflect the full population of small businesses in the U.S. The SBCS is not a random sample, which may affect the results.
The SBCS includes experiences from businesses across all 50 states and the District of Columbia through the joint efforts of the Federal Reserve Banks of New York, Atlanta, Boston, Chicago, Cleveland, Dallas, Kansas City, Minneapolis, Philadelphia, Richmond, San Francisco, and St. Louis. The 2017 SBCS collected 14,465 responses in total, 8,169 of which were from employer firms.
In this report, a business is considered to be veteran-owned if more than 50 percent of the business is owned by a veteran. Therefore, nonveteran-owned businesses also include businesses owned equally by veterans and nonveterans. In the 2017 SBCS, 6,922 respondents from employer firms shared whether they were veteran-owned or nonveteran-owned. And 696 of those respondents were from veteran-owned businesses.
Starting a Business — It’s Not for the faint of heart
So much these days is written about entrepreneurship, but perhaps too little is written about the entrepreneur. What is an entrepreneur exactly? In fact the word itself has seen dramatically increasing popularity in recent years, probably due in large part to colleges adopting entrepreneurship programs of study. But how do we define entrepreneur in dictionary
Become a Central New York Business Journal subscriber and get immediate access to all of our subscriber-only content and much more.
Click here to purchase a paywall bypass link for this article.
So much these days is written about entrepreneurship, but perhaps too little is written about the entrepreneur. What is an entrepreneur exactly? In fact the word itself has seen dramatically increasing popularity in recent years, probably due in large part to colleges adopting entrepreneurship programs of study. But how do we define entrepreneur in dictionary terms? The commonly accepted definition is: a person who organizes and operates a business or businesses, taking on greater than normal financial risks in order to do so. That sounds so simple and easy to understand, doesn’t it? I submit that starting a business involves much more than this conventional definition.
After dealing with business startups for many years I have found that it is definitely not for the faint of heart, especially in this fast paced, hyper-competitive environment that characterizes today’s business climate. Entrepreneurs have hundreds of things to consider, but let’s start at the beginning. First, there are character traits to consider. The traits that most often are noticeable in business startup founders are ambition and commitment. Ambition manifests itself in a strong desire to achieve or be successful and commitment is most often seen in unwavering determination to be successful. Needless to say, there are other qualities that are frequently exhibited by the founder of a successful startup such as drive, persistence, flexibility, and passion.
Okay, you say, everyone recognizes those necessary qualities but a lot of people have them. Exactly, that is the reason that this business-startup business is not for the faint of heart because there are dozens if not hundreds of other considerations standing in the path to success.
Let’s start with product or service. Creating a unique offering often depends on a unique idea. And many people have an interesting idea almost every day, but is it something that can be created and sold? This is where the hard work comes in and is often overlooked. Customer discovery is finding out if you have a solution to a problem or an excellent opportunity that people will actually pay for. The only way that really works well is to go out and ask people — lots of people.
Now that you’ve found a product or service that people need the fun has just begun. Considerations that must be brought to bear at this point are voluminous. Start with market research — how will you get the product to market and who exactly is your market? Now, how about a prototype to actually test market? And how are you going to finance this startup, where will the money come from? And how will you organize? — as a sole proprietor, an LLC, or will you incorporate? And where will you find your skilled employees to help you get the business off the ground? And how about pricing, engineering, distribution, legal, accounting, insurance, regulations, production, warehousing, shipping, receiving and more?
The point here is simple: over half of new business startups fail in the first five years and for good reason. Many of the above referenced considerations are overlooked, under considered, and inadequately planned for. Some of the best advice for a new business founder is to find a really good mentor that can regularly act as a sounding board and keep the entrepreneur on the right path.
Although startups are not for everyone, they can be tremendously rewarding — both personally and financially. Choosing the right team and seeking the advice that is readily available in the entrepreneurial ecosystem is so important to success.
Paul Brooks is a business advisor at the Small Business Development Center (SBDC) at Onondaga Community College. Contact him at p.c.brooks@sunyocc.edu
Stay up-to-date on the companies, people and issues that impact businesses in Syracuse, Central New York and beyond.